top of page

Selecting Navigators: 
Context, Authority & Interpretation

"Hawaiian Historiography" slides from POLS 302 course

Finding a source is only the beginning.


Strong research requires learning how to read sources carefully — and critically.

In Hawaiian and Pacific research, archives, newspapers, and scholarly works are shaped by language, power, and historical context. This section helps you practice discernment.

Activity 1: Who Is Speaking?

Choose one source (a newspaper article, archival document, or scholarly text).

Before reading closely, answer:

  • Who created this?

  • When was it written?

  • Under what political conditions?

  • Who was the intended audience?

  • Whose perspective does it center?
     

Now read the source again.
Did your understanding shift?

 

Activity 2: Reading Hawaiian-Language Sources in Context

If you are working with a Hawaiian-language text:

  • Identify key terms in ʻōlelo Hawaiʻi.

  • Look up alternate meanings or historical usage.

  • Ask: Does translation flatten or shift meaning?
     

Quick check:

  • What concepts appear central in Hawaiian but secondary in English?

  • What cultural assumptions are embedded in the language?
     

Language carries worldview. Reading requires attention.

 

Activity 3: Archive vs. Narrative

Find a primary archival record related to your topic. Then find a scholarly or community-based interpretation of the same issue.

Compare:

  • What does the archival record emphasize?

  • What does the interpretation emphasize?

  • What is missing in each?

  • How might power shape what was recorded?
     

This exercise helps you recognize that archives reflect institutional priorities, not complete realities.

 

Activity 4: Spotting Power & Framing

Take one paragraph from a source and annotate it.

Ask:

  • What words signal bias?

  • What assumptions are made?

  • What is treated as “normal” or unquestioned?

  • How might a different community describe this event?
     

Strong researchers learn to read between the lines.

 

Guiding Questions for All Research

As you work, return to these:

  • Who wrote this?

  • For whom?

  • Under what power?

  • What is emphasized?

  • What is absent?
     

Discernment is a skill. It develops through practice.

bottom of page